Also if you have a decent raid implementation you will only lose data in a single stripe or file, not everything. I am using a software raid 5 using mdadm on my ubuntu server, and so far i can only tell a slight performance difference versus the hardware one. With hardware raid, you can just connect the storage solution and start using it. A raid controller is a hardware device or software program used to manage hard disk drives hdds or solidstate drives ssds in a computer or storage array so they work as a logical unit. Jul 22, 2017 addon raid cards are generally the most flexible, scalable and bestperforming hardware setup as multiple storage and raid arrays can be added without decreasing the performance of the host system. What is the difference between a software and hardware raid. This is critical if you plan to access your raid system from a mac and a windows. Feb 28, 2018 raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology. Software raid, as you might already know, is usually builtin on your os and unlike a hardware raid, you will need to spend a little extra on a controller card. Jun 26, 2009 one of the options available to you is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution.
The mac pro raid card offers improved storage performance and data protection to your mac pro system up to 553mbs of sequential read performance in raid 0. I will tell you two reasons why i wont use software raid anymore. Yes it can happen, but it is far more rare than often claimed. Jun 26, 2019 depending on the raid controller and the amount of drives, different raid modes can be used. Compatible with different os including windows and mac. Benefits and drawbacks of hybrid, hardwareassisted software raid. Dec 01, 2014 what they dont agree on is whether software raid can replace hardware raid in many applications that need access to large volumes of digital data and content quickly. Configuration is still required, but that configuration takes place outside the system. Apples mac pro computers have the capacity of holding up to four internal hard drives, and. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the.
With software raid your data can be split across different enclosures for complete redundancy one can completely stop working and your data is still ok. So while the other hardware raid cards are great for external dives, none of them create hardware raid support for the internal drive bays of the macpro itself. Expensive hardware raid solutions are not automatically superior, often containing chips less powerful than in a standard laptop. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a raid controller card. What are the pros and cons of using the hardware raid card, vs the software raid. The raid can be implemented either using a special controller hardware raid, or by an operating system driver software raid. A hardware raid can be pricey but it helps prevent data loss and. Sep 02, 2009 mirrored and concatenated raid options in mac os x. Raid hardware is always a disk controller to which you can cable up the disk drives.
My impression is that that recovery from harddrive crashes is a bit harder with hardware raid. What they dont agree on is whether software raid can replace hardware raid in many applications that need access to large volumes of digital data and content quickly. For example, your best bet is to buy rebranded lsi cards that were made for dell or hp. Favoring hardware raid over software raid comes from a time when hardware was just not powerful enough to handle software raid processing, along with all the other tasks that it was being used for. I chose a hardware raid because of the fact that osx doesnt support it in software and i wanted a giant effing chunk of space and speed requirements are not a heavy concern of mine. Apples mac pro computers have the capacity of holding up to four internal hard drives, and all mac models support the use of external drives. Using the software supplied with the hardware raid pci card, you can. What is the difference between hardware and software raid. There is not reason to go for hardware raid just for two drives in raid 1. Standard hardware raid products only protect you from losing files when disks fail. Windows software raid vs hardware raid ars technica. Software vs hardware raid performance and cache usage server. Lenovo 46c9110 ibm serveraid m5210 storage controller raid sata 6gbs sas 12gbs low profile 1200 mbps raid 0, 1, 10 pcie 3. As drives are getting bigger we are starting moving sites away from raid 5 to raid 10 which imho will provide better protection.
It is still software but running on a dedicated controller. But with budget favoring the software raid, those wanting optimum performance and efficiency of raid will have to go with the hardware raid. Once connected, the four drive bays in the mac pro are now being controlled by the raid card, making it capable of both highspeed data transfer and more advanced raid options. Hardware raid will cost more, but it will also be free of software raid s. Can mac pro do software raid 0 for the systems disk.
In other raid configs it also allows for the array to be rebuilt with less of a performance hit on the os. Software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. In your situation, i would go with the software raid. Aug 25, 2010 software raid means that the raid is handled by the general purpose os and hardware raid means that the raid is handled by a special purpose satasas controller card that runs its own os, cpu, memory, etc. Software vs bios vs hardware raid ars technica openforum. This table summarizes the key differences between hardware and software raids. The main difference between biosfakehardware and windows software raid, as far as i know, would be. Provided you have enough machine resources cpu, ram, bus speed, and a good disk controller as a general rule, software raid will outperform hardware raid if the underlying software raid is designed well. Raid redundant array of independent disks is one of the popular data storage virtualization technology. Softraid does more by constantly checking your disks and warning you in advance before a disk fails giving you time to replace bad disks, saving precious files and data. And i also know from secondhand experience that hardware raid cards can fail. I have just installed a mac pro raid card in my 07 mac pro and the battery comes out as faulted and wont really charge.
Windows software raid and its rebranded version called storage spaces does not meet this last criteria, imo. I have been using raid on macs and pcs since 1999, and i have done it in software and 78 different kinds cards on various oses. Raid software is a set of kernel modules coupled together with management utilities that implement raid in software and require no additional. If youre serious, get a hardware controller, if not, use mac os xs software raid. A raid can be deployed using both software and hardware. This allows the raid adapter to deal with bad sectors and the best way to write data and read data. Its faster than software raid, and imo more stable, at least with a quality controller. External raid enclosures can be had using software or hardwarebased controllers. The terms hardware raid and software raid are very misleading as all raid controllers do raid using software. Under software raid, that configuration is performed in the. A hardware raid controller would be best, but the fakemotherboardneedsadriver raid is just one more thing to go wrong, and the less likely. A raid 1 will write in the same time the data to both disks taking twice as long as a raid 0, but can, in theory read twice as fast, because will read from one disk a part of the data and from another the other part, so raid 1 is not twice as bad as raid 0, both have their place.
But with budget favoring the software raid, those wanting optimum performance and. A redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability. Im using a caldigit pcie raid card in my mac pro and couldnt be happier. Well no they dont do the exact same thing, as the apple raid card provides hardware raid support to the internal drive bays of the macpro whereas all other alternatives provide hardware raid to external drives. Jun, 2016 comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. Both have physical cpu, physical memory, physical sassata controller. Create a disk set using disk utility on mac apple support. Software raid on windows tends to have a reputation for working well enough for redundancy, but not working well performancewise, but from my research it looks like it is usually raid 5 in software with windows that you really take a hit. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a special raid controller inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. Because data is processed on the card, hardware raid solutions are much more complex than software raid cards. What is the performance implication of hardware vs software. My experience with hardware and fakehardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. Installing mac os x server on a hardware raid volume because configuring the hardware raid pci card erases the operating system on the servers startup drive, you must reinstall mac os x server after you configure the card. But to appease the powers that be, i have explained the two below hardware raid is when you have a dedicated controller to do the work for you.
Solved hardware raid vs software lsi cards spiceworks. Dell perc h710 integrated raid controller card for poweredge r720, r720xd, r620, t620, r320, r520, r420, r420xr and powervault nx3200 5. One of the options available to you is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution. Imo, youre either serious about raid, or its just a toy to play with on a hobby computer. Back then, the solution was to use a hardware raid card with a builtin processor that handled the raid calculations offline.
Mar 11, 2011 i chose a hardware raid because of the fact that osx doesnt support it in software and i wanted a giant effing chunk of space and speed requirements are not a heavy concern of mine. Even the solaris zfs raid implementation has an overly complex maintenance interface when compared to the gui used by hardware raid cards. From a pure operations perspective, there is very little difference between hardware and software raid. Hardware raid is dedicated processing system, using controllers or raid cards to manage the raid configuration independently from the operating system. What is the performance implication of hardware vs. I do manipulate large images files 1 gb and in order to make the whole process faster i know that i need really fast hard drive. I need some more space, so will remove the two old drives and setup another raid. Hardware raid presents logical disks that are already configured to the system or the san, mirrored and ready to go. Hardware raid will cost more, but it will also be free of software raids. Jun 18, 2001 because data is processed on the card, hardware raid solutions are much more complex than software raid cards. We list the pros and cons of hardware vs software raid to help you. Many people wrongly view software raid as a less powerful, cheap solution. Mirrored and concatenated raid options in mac os x.
On the other hand, some raid cards introduce speed issues rather than solving them, we are way past the point where the cpu was important in raid setups, raid 1 has no calculation of parity anyway, so, unless you like to learn something and test various scenarios, dont even think of a raid controller for raid1 ssd. Owc 40tb thunderbay 4 mini ssd with raid0 stripe and raid4 fault tolerance. It is used to improve disk io performance and reliability of your server or workstation. My experience with hardware and fake hardware raid is that as long as you stay with the same vendor, the raid metadata will be recognized ive seen this when moving drives between various hp, areca and lsi hardware raid controllers, and with intel, amd and even via hostraid i was pretty surprised when i connected a 250gb hard drive from some old amd desktop box to a hp g1 microserver, and. All of todays operating systems have some form of software raid built into them os x, windows 710 and linux.
But the real question is whether you should use a hardware raid solution or a software raid solution. Over the last few years sata disk controller cards and motherboards have come out. You can easily move disks from a failed enclosure to a new one, and all your data is preserved. Hardware raid cards must include memory for cache as well as extra controls to power. It combines multiple inexpensive, small disk drives into an array of disks in order to provide redundancy, lower latency maximizing the chanc. Learn more about software and hardware raid volumes akitio. For hardware raid, that cpu can be in a disk array or in a raid controller. Imho, im a big fan of kernel developers non directly related to zfs, so i really prefere mdadm to hardware raid.
Ultimately, the difference comes down to where the raid processing is performed. Mirrored and concatenated raid options in mac os x cnet. Additionally, hardwareassisted software raid usually comes with a variety of drivers for the most popular operating systems, and therefore, is more os independent than pure software raid. Software raid, such as softraid, can provide incredibly fast read and write speeds. Addon raid cards are generally the most flexible, scalable and bestperforming hardware setup as multiple storage and raid arrays can be added. Regarding their differences, hw raid is usually hassle free and usually comes with hotswapability. With the optional hardware raid pci card installed in your xserve g5 system, you can create a raid array that uses the systems drive modules and takes advantage of the. For example, with a softraid volume, you can only use it with computers running mac os. Windows software raid vs hardware raid 10 posts arlesterc.
Softraid hands down is a better solution than apple raid and does not lock you into hardware raid cards which do fail and leave you in a bad situation. With cheaper hardware raid you can also lose data if theres a power outage. Linuxbased software raid is regarded as mature and very usable. Hardware redundant array of inexpensive disks raid and software raid are two main ways for setting up raid system. External enclosure raid vs software raid spiceworks. Apple raid configuration vs hardware raid super user. Strangely the system information doesnt show anything on hardware raid, or pci cards. Akitios data storage products make use of both hardware and software raid, depending the model.
Software raid supports variable size volumes that can be extended by adding more disks specifically zfs supports this, maybe others do as well. Perhaps this is because the driver in that modified kext is version 1. A hardware raid is created by a builtin raid controller and is independent of the computer and the operating system. Im only using the raid card for personal use from what i. The hardware raid card can work effectively in larger servers as well as on a desktop computer. Also if you experience a corrupted os hardware raid remains unaffected while software raid will be lost, so hardware raid is generally more secure. In a hardware raid setup, the drives connect to a raid controller card inserted in a fast pciexpress pcie slot in a motherboard. Comparing hardware raid vs software raid setups deals with how the storage drives in a raid array connect to the motherboard in a server or pc, and the management of those drives. Having said that, the above is because of the bbued cache.
You can also create a set that concatenates smaller disks to act as one larger disk. Whether software raid vs hardware raid is the one for you depends on what you need to do and how much you want to pay. You connect the raid box to your mac, install software that lets os x talk. Jul 07, 2009 a redundant array of inexpensive disks raid allows high levels of storage reliability.
1563 308 590 96 725 276 716 1385 424 1412 1039 1249 1420 1354 938 728 1544 1342 496 44 980 117 1372 607 461 1058 591 1543 42 892 767 847 914 666 1468 940 1008 240 83 1270 817 845 995 149 1217 598 303